Books

On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will

Free Read On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will - by Martin Luther Henry Cole - On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will, On the Bondage of the Will Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free will First published in Martin Luther s Bondage of the Will is acknowledged by theologians as one of the great masterpieces of the Reformation It is Luther s response to Desiderius Erasmus s Diatribe

  • Title: On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will
  • Author: Martin Luther Henry Cole
  • ISBN: 2940020800960
  • Page: 365
  • Format: Nook

Free Read On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will - by Martin Luther Henry Cole, On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will, Martin Luther Henry Cole, On the Bondage of the Will Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free will First published in Martin Luther s Bondage of the Will is acknowledged by theologians as one of the great masterpieces of the Reformation It is Luther s response to Desiderius Erasmus s Diatribe on Free Will written in his direct and unique style combining deep spirituality with humor Luther writes powerf Free Read On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will - by Martin Luther Henry Cole - On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will, On the Bondage of the Will Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free will First published in Martin Luther s Bondage of the Will is acknowledged by theologians as one of the great masterpieces of the Reformation It is Luther s response to Desiderius Erasmus s Diatribe

  • Free Read On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will - by Martin Luther Henry Cole
    365Martin Luther Henry Cole
On the Bondage of the Will: Written in Answer to the Diatribe of Erasmus on Free-will

About "Martin Luther Henry Cole"

  1. Martin Luther Henry Cole

    Martin Luther was a German monk, theologian, university professor and church reformer whose ideas inspired the Protestant Reformation and changed the course of Western civilization.Luther s theology challenged the authority of the papacy by holding that the Bible is the only infallible source of religious authority and that all baptized Christians under Jesus are a spiritual priesthood According to Luther, salvation was a free gift of God, received only by true repentance and faith in Jesus as the Messiah, a faith given by God and unmediated by the church.Luther s confrontation with Charles V at the Diet of Worms over freedom of conscience in 1521 and his refusal to submit to the authority of the Emperor resulted in his being declared an outlaw of the state as he had been excommunicated from the Roman Catholic Church Because of the perceived unity of the medieval Church with the secular rulers of western Europe, the widespread acceptance of Luther s doctrines and popular vindication of his thinking on individual liberties were both phenomenal and unprecedented.His translation of the Bible into the vernacular, making it accessible to ordinary people, had a tremendous political impact on the church and on German culture It furthered the development of a standard version of the German language, added several principles to the art of translation, and influenced the translation of the English King James Bible His hymns inspired the development of congregational singing within Christianity His marriage to Katharina von Bora set a model for the practice of clerical marriage within Protestantism.Much scholarly debate has concentrated on Luther s writings about the Jews His statements that Jews homes should be destroyed, their synagogues burned, money confiscated and liberty curtailed were revived and used in propaganda by the Nazis in 1933 45 As a result of this and his revolutionary theological views, his legacy remains controversial.

141 Comments


  1. D sir rasme est une grande figure de l humanisme c est un peu gr ce lui que j ai commenc lire, apr s que la biographie que Zweig lui a consacr me soit tomb e dans les mains J ai appr ci son loge de la folie, qui m a attir vers l antiquit , et je me r gale de ses Adages, qui ont t r cemment r dit s gr ce l industrieuse rudition de nos savants Luther, je le connais par la biographie r dig e par Michelet, et le personnage m avait vivement int ress La question de la volont libre, c est le formidable [...]


  2. This book was very difficult to get through because so much was packed in each sentence While reading this book I found myself on a number of occasions reading less than a page in a sitting With that said, this book was worth the effort.Luther absolutely obliterates Erasmus, and he is anything but cordial in doing so This book is laden with sarcasm, insult, and downright nastiness at times This book is as intense as a polemic could be While I typically tire of fundamentalist polemics, this book [...]


  3. In the chapter before the conclusion of On the Bondage of the Will, Luther belches out this rather shocking paragraph Only observe, therefore, the simplicity of the words By the law is the knowledge of sin and yet, these alone are of force sufficient to confound and overthrow Free will altogether For if it be true, that of itself, it knows not what is sin, and what is evil, as the apostle saith here, and Rom vii 7 8, I should not have known that concupiscence was sin, except the law had said, Th [...]


  4. An attractive unabridged translation of Martin Luther s magnum opus, Bondage of the Will stands out as a theological gemstone packaged into 250 pages of Luther s diatribe at its best Written as a response to the Catholic theologian Erasmus of Rotterdam s defense of freedom of the will, Luther sets out on one mission only destroy any inclination of free will His weapon of choice The scriptures alone, for they speaks for themselves sharper than a double edged sword, Luther smashes any effort by Er [...]


  5. Excellent engagement with the various passages used by Erasmus to support the Catholic view of free will in salvation Also, very helpful images throughout to explain the arguments One image I found particularly helpful Erasmus posited that God would not give man a command for instance, to believe unto salvation without also giving him the ability to comply Luther counters with the image of a man who is bound from head to toe in chains but who believes himself unencumbered One might command the b [...]




  6. Luther s, The Bondage of the Will, is a doctrinal treatise first arguing against Erasmus doctrine of free will, and then arguing for the Bible doctrine of the will s bondage Luther argues that, counter to Erasmus view, man is not able to freely choose Christ for his salvation Man is enslaved in his sin and unable to act in any way towards his own salvation Apart from divinely initiated grace, man is incapable of not only meriting salvation through his works, but of even choosing God Luther s sty [...]


  7. 3 20 2011 halfway through the first part of the DiscussionKeep feeling like I m taking it in great gulps and then realize only 30 pages have passed this definitely takes concentration as each sentence is full I ve ended up reading half of it out loud and for some reason it seems to be clearer this way The parts where he focuses on the issue at hand are definitely better important informative grace filled than the parts where he s lashing away at Erasmus, tearing him into itty bitty teeny tin [...]


  8. I don t know whether it is the translators translation or Luther alone, probably both, but Luther was killer Erasmus did not have a prayer, literally, it seems.A powerful wit One who talks as you do must imagine that the living God is no than a wild inconsequent ranter shouting from a soap box, whose words you may interpret, receive or refute as you please, according to their observed effect on the ungodly.An insightful heart I frankly confess that, for myself, even if it could be, I should not [...]


  9. Luther is writing this as a response to Erasmus, who was a well known humanist scholar Erasmus decided to stay within the Roman Catholic church Erasmus wants Luther to see the ramifications of saying, there is no free will However, Luther forcefully counters all the polemics made by Erasmus.He says, everything is by God and if he is omniscient, his immutable will shall prevail no matter what I could really feel Luther s caustic words He quotes a lot of scriptures and simply shows that it does no [...]


  10. Empassioned defense by Luther of our human inability to win God s favor by making right choices and living an upright moral life He is saracastic, satirical and whimsical in his rebuttal of the learned and famous Erasmus of Rotterdam who relied heavily on the interpretations of Jerome and Origen to bolster his support for a semi Pelagian form of synergism Erasmus, following Duns Scotus and other medieval scholastics, argues for our human abilities, damaged from the fall of humanity, but often op [...]


  11. Luther admitted he thought this was his best work and I am inclined to agree In this response to Erasmus of Rotterdam he presents a compelling case for the exhaustive sovereignty of God over all of creation and particularly in electing and predestining those whom he saves, he also shows how this does not conflict with the idea that man is held responsible for his sin, addressing the same question Paul does in Romans 9, How can God still blame us, if no one resists his will Luther s writing is sh [...]


  12. I found this book to be a real diatribe It reads heavilyy, with long sentences, and lack of punctuation The fire of Luther is very apparent.It s not a technical book, but the same arguments we have today, over free will and the will bound, abounded then The low road of Erasmus, is still present today, in the free will or synergetic salvation churches.The high road view of Luther, based on St Augustine, and that held by Calvin, is the minority of reformed churches today.It s a read to be had, non [...]


  13. This book helped me a lot with understanding the argument of free will and predestination I ve always understood the basic arguments, but once I started thinking deeper into the topics, things weren t as clear for me This really helped me understand the deeper issues So even though it was hard to read, I m so glad I read it because of that Unfortunately, I had to read through it kind of quickly because I read it for a class and had a deadline to finish it by So I wasn t really able to read throu [...]


  14. Acutally, I heard this on sermonaudio, which means not all of it sank in, but I got the gist of it Luther was a deep thinker, and he has many good points here, most of which I agree with At times he was perhaps a little too harsh and dogmatic, but overall a good book to sink your teeth into It probably deserves than three stars, but it was not the most easy listen, and thus not the most enjoyable to me.


  15. Don t have time, or the ability to write a review of such a work Suffice it to say the book was excellent, humorous, and helpful I wish I could recommend it to so many people, unfortunately the people today proclaiming free will aren t typically the kind of people to read much, and definitely not Reformation Era Anyway, great read And, I appreciate the respect Luther pays to Erasmus at the end It really shows Luther was about the issue, the biggest issue, rather than about Erasmus.


  16. Profound in spots and contradictory in many others I did not care for Luther as an author by this sample of his writing, and did not like his style of argument, but I am still glad that I chose it for a college research paper I like some of the passages, which are quite quotable, but some of it does get heavy I would recommend this to serious students of theology and mature Christians.


  17. Luther is an utter jackass when writing this book While there may be stylistic differences between how people wrote in the 16th Century to now, there s not a whit of Christian charity show in the tone of the book I found myself sympathetic to Erasmus than The Great Reformer.


  18. Amazing Luther is so clear, so blunt, so biblical I thought reading this would be very difficult, but it was a joy The translators have much to do with this experience, I m sure, and their introduction was exceptionally helpful



  19. FINALLY finished a most elegant and thorough treatment of man s free will before a Sovereign God.Luther may touch on all possibilities regarding man s free will I highly recommend this book to any of who wants to understand God s sovereignty and man s free will.


  20. I wonder how I would have received The Bondage of the Will had I read it just a few years earlier in my life After all, here is one of those books that represents a major dichotomy in Christian belief and practice on the one side those who hold that the Gospel has the power of transformation, and on the other side moralism and good deeds In Luther s time, this manifested in the dichotomy of the Catholic Church and Luther s community of rebels, but in our day and age this dichotomy manifests most [...]


  21. I have to admit I read this book probably 30 plus years ago now and I still refer back to it occasionally What prompted me to read it was because I heard some quotes and his name was dropped into sermons and conversations often enough to know this guy was important in the history of the church and I should read some source material I certainly was not prepared for this book it was both very difficult to read and I struggled with his concepts, no doubt to a lack of ability in me to think critical [...]


  22. A lot of ink has been shed debating the nature and ability of man s will as it relates to doing good, and for anyone who would discuss this topic with well informed knowledge of what each position holds, Luther s De Servo Arbitrio or On Bondage of the Will is an important voice in that conversation.This seminal work of Luther s was incredibly illuminating into the issue of so called free will In it Luther interacts with Erasmus work On Free Will Erasmus, as a medieval humanist, contended for the [...]


  23. This edition J.I Packer as Translator is brought forth with a flair for the dramatic Packer states in the beginning that he is translating in the spirit of the matter and not necessarily the literal work Because I know this work, the history of this work and I know of the men involved, I am confident in the effort to hold true to Luther s intent That being said, this is one of the best books I have read.If you hate Jesus, if you are a card carrying Catholic or a card carrying Baptist, you will p [...]


  24. An excellent critique on Free Will.I don t really take to the idea of Free will as long as we are conditioned by Time, Place, and Education, but Luther s criticism of free will against Erasmus was magisterial.One of the things I find Christianity to be is that it is really hard to argue due to its inconsistency, especially on free will In the New Testament, you find that Paul says we have free will while still God makes vessels unto honor and to dishonor and while in the Old testament God harden [...]


  25. I LOVED this book Being brought up German Lutheran, where we sat in the pews like good little soldiers, as a childhood friend of mine put it, I never imagined Luther to be laugh out loud funny My image of him was always Stacy Keach prostrate on the floor of the sanctuary enduring penance for some miniscule sin, or of course drily giving us the answer to, what does this mean This book is like a 500 year old Facebook argument The one we all wish we could have It is a truly beautiful and remarkable [...]


  26. The Bondage of the Will was Martin Luther s reply to Erasmus On Free Will Consequently most of the book is a rebuttal to Erasmus whom I, nor I suppose, most have read So one must construct Erasmus argument from Luther, and much of the context of the argument is somewhat difficult to follow for this reason.Luther does decimate whatever modicum of an argument Erasmus must have used, as he shows clearly from Scripture and reason why free will is nonsense Sin has incapacitated man s ability to make [...]


Leave a Comment